Beautiful cinematography and a rich visual style with some interesting action
sequences are found throughout this Japanese take on American Westerns. Directed by
Miike Takashi and including an extended cameo with Quentin Tarantino, Sukiyaki
Western Django has a good solid start.
If you know your Japanese history, the rival clans that appear make sense. The Genji
and Heike clans fought each other viciously. In Sukiyaki Western Django the Heike
clan wears red and the Genji wear white. Simple enough. In one part of the movie a
character is seen with a copy of "The Tales of the Heike", a work of Classical
Japanese Literature that depicts the wars between the Heike and the Genji.
In a small town called Yuta in the Nevata Village, a gunman arrives to help a woman
who is forced into prostitution, get her revenge. Soon both the Heike and Genji
clans arrive to battle.
As stunning as Sukiyaki Western Django is to watch, there are a few problems. First
the characters in both clans are just rivals like the Hatfield and McCoys that are
already in the middle of fighting each other. There is no back-story as to why the
feud is going on. It would have been interesting if Miike inserted a flashback or
used dialogue to flesh out the two lead rivals. Miike does do a good job telling the
story of the prostitute and her son, the mute boy. Even Tarantino has a back-story
as you see him in the beginning as a young man and at the end as a old man. Props to
the makeup department for Tarantino's old man makeup.
Some of the action shots are well done and fast-paced that every good Western should
have. However, others are long and drawn out with exaggerated attempts at humor that
are not that funny.
In one scene, a Heike clan member is being shot several times and never seems to
die. Despite numerous life-ending shots, the actor does a series of exaggerated
dying gestures without ever dying and appears healthy and alive later. The dying
scenes look about as well as any child playing Cowboys and Indians could perform.
The weakest aspect of Sukiyaki Western Django is the plot which is barely present.
Basically a prostitute wants revenge, an unnamed gunman comes to help, and rival
clans fight each other in a small Japanese village designed to look like the Old
American West. If the characters were better developed, then the lack of plot would
not be so bad. However, without much of a plot and clan members that you never care
about; there is not much happening.
On the positive side, you do empathize with the young mute boy and the boy's mother,
the prostitute, and to some extent the gunman.
Taking as a whole, Sukiyaki Western Django is a flashy red Lamborghini lacking a
good engine. This movie is definitely worth a look as a rental. Repeated viewings
will not reveal any hidden truths or enjoyment. That is not to say Miike is a bad
director, only that this is a minor work. To see a good Miike movie, check out
Audition.
2 Stars out of 4.
To comment on this or any other PCR article, please visit The Message Board. "The Asian Aperture" is ©2010 by Jason Fetters. Webpage design and all graphics herein (except where otherwise noted) are creations of Nolan B. Canova. All contents of Nolan's Pop Culture Review are ©2010 by Nolan B. Canova.